This post may contain affiliate links. You can read my full affiliate disclosure here.

Regular Toothpaste vs. Gel: Difference to Consider

The battle between regular toothpaste and gel toothpaste has been one that’s been going on for centuries– okay, maybe not centuries, but it sure feels like it! But what are the differences between these two types of toothpaste? Let’s take a look at some key points to consider when deciding which one is right for you.

Regular toothpaste is made from a paste or cream-like substance, whereas gel toothpastes are usually clear in appearance. Regular toothpaste tends to have more additives such as fluoride, baking soda and other cleaning agents than gels do. This means regular toothpaste may be more effective at removing plaque and preventing cavities. However, some people may prefer gel toothpastes since they don’t contain any of these additives and can be gentler on the teeth.

Regular toothpastes tend to foam up more than gels, which can make them easier to spread around in your mouth. Gels, while being generally less foamy, may still have some foaming properties due to certain ingredients like baking soda or glycerin. This means that gels could help keep plaque away for longer periods of time if used regularly.

When it comes to taste, regular toothpaste is usually minty fresh and gels are often flavorless or lightly flavored with a floral aroma. Some people feel that brushing with a gel gives them better breath because there is no strong flavor lingering in their mouths after they brush their teeth.

Does Tooth Gel Work Better Than A Regular Toothpaste?


Feature Tom's of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque & Whitening Natural Toothpaste, Peppermint, 5.5 oz. 2-Pack (Packaging May Vary)

Regular Toothpaste

LIVFRESH Dental Gel by Livionex (Formerly Livionex Dental Gel) - Clinically Proven to Remove Plaque 250% Better (Whitening, Non-Foaming, Peppermint)

Gel Toothpaste

Consistency Smooth paste Gel-like consistency
Flavor Variety of flavors, including mint, cinnamon, and bubblegum Also available in a variety of flavors
Ingredients Generally contains fluoride, a mild abrasive, and a binder to hold the paste together Similar ingredients to regular toothpaste, with the addition of a thickening agent to give it a gel-like consistency
Effectiveness Effective at preventing tooth decay and promoting good oral hygiene Also effective at preventing tooth decay and promoting good oral hygiene
Taste Strong mint flavor Strong mint flavor
Popularity A staple in the toothpaste market Gaining popularity but yet to match the popularity of regular toothpaste
Sensitivity Some toothpastes are formulated specifically for individuals with sensitive teeth and gums also some toothpaste are formulated for sensitivity
Whitening Some toothpastes contain whitening agents Also some toothpaste contains whitening agents
Tartar control Some toothpastes are formulated to help control the buildup of tartar on the teeth Also some toothpastes are formulated to help control the buildup of tartar on the teeth
Natural or Organic Some toothpastes are made with natural or organic ingredients Some toothpastes are made with natural or organic ingredients
Cost Some toothpastes are more expensive than others, depending on the ingredients and brand Some toothpastes are more expensive than others, depending on the ingredients and brand
Packaging Some toothpaste comes in tube Some toothpaste comes in jar or box
Brand Some toothpastes are available in different brand Some toothpastes are available in different brand
Special claims Some toothpaste may have special claims like “Fights against bad breath” or “Gum protection” Some toothpaste may have special claims like “Fights against bad breath” or “Gum protection”

There are many factors that can make gel toothpaste seem like they work better than regular ones. For example, some people think that the higher viscosity of a gel paste makes teeth cleaning more thorough and effective because it has an easier time getting into all those nooks and crannies in your mouth. Others believe that the foamier texture of regular toothpaste is what helps cleanse their pearly whites – while this may not be true for everyone, there is still science to back up why both types have different benefits. It’s really hard to say which one truly works best as long as you’re using them consistently (which we hope you will!), so don’t worry about trying out different toothpasty brands until you find one that you love.

We hope this post helped to clarify the differences between gel toothpaste and regular ones! If you have any questions or concerns about either of these products, be sure to contact your dentist for more information on their use. You can also read my blog if you want some additional oral care tips!

What are Gel Toothpaste’s Pros & Cons?

*Pros: Many people claim that because a gel paste is thicker than its traditional counterpart, it will clean teeth better as well as help reduce plaque buildup by coating them with foamier texture. The same goes for whitening – many people find that their teeth look whiter after using gel toothpaste thanks to the higher viscosity.

*Cons: It is possible that individuals may not like the texture of gel toothpaste because it can feel slippery and slimy when in contact with your teeth. Those who are looking for an extra “foaming” action might also prefer to use regularly over gel as they believe this type of paste creates more foam than its counterpart. The next con would be price – many people find that a tube or jar of gel toothpaste costs significantly more than one without, which could lead to some sticker shock in terms of how much you spend on oral care products each year!

What Are Regular Toothpastes Pros & Cons?

*Pros: Some say that while there are no differences between using either type, some people may think they have whiter teeth after brushing their pearly whites with a regular toothpaste. There is also an argument that the foamier consistency of this type of paste makes it more effective when used for whitening purposes because there are usually higher levels of acid (which can break down stains).

*Cons: One downside to using regular toothpaste is how much work it takes to get out all those pesky food particles from in between your front teeth and elsewhere on your mouth – some say that gel pastes are better at getting these bits out than traditional ones. Another con would be the taste – many find that the flavor or texture isn’t as pleasant, especially if you’re someone who likes minty flavors like “Peppermint” or “Spearmint”.

Tooth gel and Toothpaste: Which Should You Choose?


Choosing which type of toothpaste to buy can be difficult, especially if you’re not completely sure what the difference is. We hope this blog post helped clear up some confusion and gave you a better understanding of how both types work! Keep in mind that there are pros and cons for each so it’s always best to try out other brands until you find one that meets your needs – at least then we know for sure what works best for you. If any questions or concerns arise, pop us an email or give your dentist a call ASAP!

Toothpaste vs gel, regular vs whitening: What should I use?

Regular Toothpaste versus Gel Toothpaste- Which is Better Anyway? Like many things in life , choosing between two things to do is always difficult, especially when it comes to oral care products. While there are many reasons why one might be a better choice over the other (and vice versa), we can only provide you with what’s been backed up by science so far – and that’s both types of toothpaste have their own strengths and weaknesses. It’ll all depend on your preferences as an individual which type will work best for you!

*Regular Toothpaste: Some people find this product works great because they think their teeth look whiter after using regular paste than if they were just brushing with water or another rinse-free option. It also provides a more foamy action so those who are looking for extra “clean” may prefer this product.

*Gel Toothpaste: For those who want a thicker, more viscous consistency to coat their teeth and help reduce plaque buildup or whiter teeth, this is the right choice for you. Gel toothpastes also tend to taste better than regular ones which could be appealing if you like peppermint flavors such as “Peppermint” or “Spearmint”. The downside of using a gel toothpaste comes when it’s time to clean your mouth – some find that getting particles out from between front teeth can be difficult because not all types have fluoride in them so they don’t break down stains evenly (like traditional paste). Much like its name suggests, many people feel that unless one prefers having fresher breath with an “in-your-face” flavor, gel toothpaste is the way to go.

Other Factors to Consider:

*Cost: The average person spends about $150 per year on oral care products. If you’re someone who prefers gel toothpaste, the cost can range anywhere from an additional $0 to nearly triple that amount depending on where you buy it and what brand is chosen. This could be a con if one doesn’t have much money but may also be good for those looking to make minimal investments in their long-term health as well! For some people, there’s nothing better than having whiter teeth so they might choose to spend more money upfront just because their mouth needs are different than others’.

*Preference: Some people prefer gel toothpaste while other like regular paste – this will depend greatly on your specific taste preference or need . If you’re someone who likes the flavor or wants a more foamy action, regular toothpaste is for you. For those with sensitive teeth and prefer thinner substances to coat them, gel toothpaste could be your best bet! Always remember to try out different brands until one seems like it’s right for you – at least then we know that specific product works well before investing in too many tubes of something that may not meet our needs.

*Sensitivity: Everyone responds differently when it comes to certain types of products, including dental ones as well. Some people might feel sensitivity if they use traditional paste because there are harsh-looking ingredients within it which sometimes can cause discomfort on parts such as the gums while others don’t notice any difference whatsoever . If you’re someone who has sensitive teeth, gel toothpaste is a better alternative for you because the consistency helps soothe some of the discomfort and doesn’t rely on ingredients to work.

*Fluoride: One thing that both types have in common is fluoride – which can help reduce cavities and strengthen your teeth if used regularly . This ingredient isn’t present within all products but those with it are always great to use as they boost oral health even more!

*Rinse-Free Products: We’ve already mentioned them briefly before but not everyone wants their mouth coated in something after brushing (think of what food tastes like afterward). For these people, rinse-free options such as air dry or water might be best for their preferences. Of course, there are some who prefer to wait for a minute before they clean their teeth and might also find that an air dry is the way to go.

*Tongue Coating: Everyone’s mouth is different so what one person finds to be just right could be too much for someone else. For example, some people might find that gel toothpaste coats their tongue too heavily while others might not mind the thickness at all – this will depend on you and how sensitive you are/how quickly things get coated in your mouth.

*Breath Freshener: Some orthodontic treatments can cause a decrease in breath freshening abilities due to worn out teeth or an increased level of metal which means using gum or mints is sometimes necessary . However, if you’re someone who doesn’t require such products then gel toothpaste should work great as far as freshening breath goes!

*Cavities: Gel toothpaste might be a better option if you have cavities as the consistency can help coat them and strengthen teeth in certain cases. If this is something that’s been present for awhile, it may not work overnight but gel toothpaste does seem to provide some good benefits in such situations.

*Whitening Toothpaste: This type of product aims to whiten one’s teeth by increasing the surface area upon which stains are more visible . One downside to these types of products is they’re usually pricey – so be sure before buying any kind of whitener from your local drugstore or pharmacy that you really need it because there are plenty other ways to get whiter teeth without spending an arm and a leg.

*Smooth Texture: If you’re someone who likes smoother products to use, gel toothpaste is the way to go! It’s not as gritty or sticky as regular paste which means it’ll be easier on your teeth during brushing.

Do gels clean as well as pastes?


A common misconception is that gels do not clean as well as traditional toothpastes, but this does not seem to be the case! If you go into a store and ask for “regular” or “classic” paste, they will offer you many different types of gel options. Gels can also contain fluoride which makes them more potent at preventing cavities – so it might work better if your teeth are sensitive or have cavities.

I’ve heard gels are cleaner. Is this true?

Gels are not necessarily cleaner. In fact, many gels contain harsh-looking ingredients which sometimes can cause discomfort on parts such as the gums because they rely more heavily on these ingredients to work rather than just being a paste. Gel toothpaste also tends to be more expensive and there’s no evidence that it does anything better for teeth or oral health in general so this is something you must consider before buying any kind of gel product from your local drugstore or pharmacy.


In addition to regular toothpaste and gel toothpaste, there are several other types of toothpaste that are available on the market that may be relevant to consider, some of them are:

Powdered toothpaste: a dry powder that is mixed with water to create a paste before brushing. Some powdered toothpastes are made with natural ingredients, such as charcoal or baking soda, and may be suitable for individuals looking for a more natural oral care option.


  • Can be made with natural ingredients like charcoal or baking soda
  • May be a more natural oral care option
  • Can be used as a substitute for toothpaste in travel or outdoor scenarios
  • Can be a cost-effective option as it can be used for longer period of time


  • Not as widely available as traditional toothpaste
  • May be messier to use and can be hard to measure out the correct amount
  • Not as well known and may be harder to find specific brand or flavors

Liquid toothpaste: a liquid that is applied to the toothbrush before brushing. Some liquid toothpastes are formulated for individuals with sensitive teeth and gums and may have different ingredients than regular toothpastes.


  • Some liquid toothpastes are formulated for individuals with sensitive teeth and gums
  • Can be a more natural oral care option
  • May be more travel-friendly than traditional toothpaste tubes


  • Not as widely available as traditional toothpaste
  • Some people may not be comfortable with the consistency
  • Not as well known and may be harder to find specific brand or flavors

Tablets toothpaste: these are bite-size tablets that are chewed to release the toothpaste and then brushed with a wet toothbrush. This type of toothpaste may be a convenient option for travelers or for individuals who prefer not to use traditional toothpaste tubes.


  • Convenient option for travelers
  • Can be a more sustainable option as it eliminates the need for traditional toothpaste tubes
  • Some people may find the experience of chewing the tablets before brushing to be more enjoyable than traditional toothpaste


  • Not as widely available as traditional toothpaste
  • Some people may find it hard to chew the tablets
  • Not as well known and may be harder to find specific brand or flavors

Natural toothpaste: This toothpaste are made from all natural ingredients like neem, clove, tulsi, clove etc. Without any added chemicals or preservatives. Some people prefer to use natural toothpaste for oral care for avoiding artificial ingredient.


  • Made from all-natural ingredients like neem, clove, tulsi, clove etc.
  • No added chemicals or preservatives
  • Some people may prefer to avoid artificial ingredients in their oral care products


  • Not as widely available as traditional toothpaste
  • Not as well known and may be harder to find specific brand or flavors
  • Some natural toothpaste may not be as effective as toothpaste with added chemicals

It’s worth noting that not all of these alternatives are widely available and some of them can be hard to find in regular stores. Additionally, as always, it’s important to read the label and ingredient list carefully when choosing a toothpaste, regardless of the type, to ensure that it meets your oral care needs and preferences.


Q: Which type of toothpaste should I use?

A: Ultimately, your choice in toothpaste should be based on personal preference. Some people may prefer the taste or texture of one type over another while others may find that they get better results with one type rather than the other. It is important to note, however, that both regular toothpaste and gel toothpaste are effective at cleaning teeth when used in accordance with proper brushing techniques.

Q: What benefits does each type of toothpaste provide?

A: Regular toothpaste provides many of the same benefits as gel toothpastes but with a more traditional feel. This type of toothpaste can help reduce plaque buildup, combat cavities and leave teeth feeling clean and refreshed. Gel toothpaste, on the other hand, typically offers extra protection against bacteria and can help to soothe gums. Additionally, gel toothpastes often come in flavored varieties that can make brushing a more enjoyable experience.

Q: Are there any drawbacks to using either type of toothpaste?

A: Generally speaking, both regular and gel toothpastes are safe to use when used properly. However, some people may be sensitive to the abrasives found in regular toothpaste which can cause irritation in the mouth or on the gums. Gel toothpaste may also contain ingredients like sugars or artificial sweeteners that can increase levels of plaque on teeth if consumed excessively. It is important to read labels carefully before purchasing either type of toothpaste so that you can understand what ingredients it contains and make an informed decision about which product is best for you.


Gel toothpaste is a viable alternative to regular paste because it doesn’t rely on harsh ingredients and can help your teeth in various ways. It’s important to find the product that works best for you, so always try out different brands until one seems like it’s right for you – at least then we know that specific product works well before investing in too many tubes of something that may not meet our needs!