There are a lot of different things to consider when choosing toothpaste. The ingredients, the packaging, and how it tastes all play important roles in your decision-making process. But one thing that often gets overlooked is whether or not the toothpaste you’re using is organic. What makes this such an important distinction? Dentists say organic is better because their products don’t contain any toxic ingredients which can lead to health problems like cavities, inflammation of the gingiva (gums), and even cancer! In this article, we’ll discuss what natural toothpaste have that other brands may lack and why dentists recommend them as a healthy alternative for your teeth.
An in-depth review of natural toothpastes. Find out what natural toothpaste might be best for you making the switch!
Now, I’ve been searching for a natural toothpaste for quite a while now. I’ve actually tried six different brands, and I’m going to review them from worst to the best.
Of course, dental hygiene is super important and whatever we put in our mouth is actually directly absorbed into the bloodstream because of our gums. Our gums are kind of like pathways to our bloodstreams, so it’s really important to put something near your gums that’s safe for you to use.
Conventional toothpastes contain a lot of artificial additives, and a lot of these additives are actually linked to cancer. There’s also chemicals that are hormone disruptors, and a lot of whitening toothpastes out there actually contain microbeads, and those little microbeads get stuck under the gums, and they create openings for bacteria to get in, and they actually cause gum disease in the long runs.
Now, the toothpastes that I’ll be talking about don’t contain fluoride. Now, there’s a big debate about fluoride, because fluoride is important to keep your teeth healthy, but it also causes all kinds of other problems. It can cause dental fluorosis, which it basically means that the enamel doesn’t harden properly. Fluoride can also be toxic for your kidneys, and it can cause gastrointestinal issues later on. Now, you can discuss this with your dentist and see what works for you. Now, there is natural toothpaste with fluoride in it, so if you are really set on using fluoride in your toothpaste, you can go ahead and use those.
After reading so many scary things about conventional toothpaste, I did decide to make the switch to natural toothpaste. Let’s go through the toothpastes that I actually liked and disliked. I’ll start with the toothpaste that are at the bottom of the list, and I’ll go up to my favorites.
What is natural toothpaste?
Natural toothpaste is a paste made of natural ingredients. It contains no artificial colorings, sweeteners, sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), fluoride and many other chemicals that are not only unnecessary but may also have harmful side effects. The following tips will help you find the best natural toothpaste for your needs:
What does organic mean when used to describe oral care products? “Organic” generally refers to something grown without pesticides in accordance with guidelines set by an international certification organization such as USDA Organic. This applies to anything from vegetables and fruits to animal foods like dairy products and eggs; even bottled water can be certified under these standards! But what does this mean for oral care?
What is the best natural toothpaste? In order to find the best natural toothpaste, you need to first identify your needs. If your priority in a product is organic content and environmental sustainability, then choose an option that has at least 50% organic ingredients or less than 25% synthetic preservatives such as propylene glycol which is used for preserving oral care products like mouthwash.
What are the benefits of natural toothpaste? The key to a healthy mouth starts with oral care. Natural toothpaste is an easy way for you to take control over your oral health, and they provide many advantages like removing plaque and fighting gum disease in order to prevent issues that would require more extensive dental work such as root canals or crowns.
Organic Toothpaste Is More Effective Than Standard Toothpastes At Fighting Gum Disease And Plaque Buildup! In one study published by the Journal of International Oral Health, researchers found out that toothbrush bristles alone were ineffective at removing plaque from teeth when compared against manual brushing with a natural toothpaste containing ¾ active ingredients.
Natural Toothpaste Is More Viscous And Thicker Than Regular Toothpastes. This means that you’ll need to use less toothpaste and it will stay on the brush longer, allowing for better contact with your teeth.
The Difference Between Organic vs Standard Toothpastes
There are many different types of natural toothpaste available today, but there is a big difference between standard and organic toothpaste when it comes to effectiveness in fighting plaque buildup and gum disease because they contain drastically different ingredients. The main ingredient in most regular toothpaste brands is sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) which has been shown to be very harmful as well as abrasive due to its chemical composition. Organic toothpaste, on the other hand, contains natural surfactants like organic aloe vera and xylitol which provide a milder scrubbing effect that is less abrasive.
The Benefits of Natural Toothpastes
Natural toothpaste doesn’t contain any additives or artificial ingredients – so you know exactly what’s going into your mouth. It also has an added benefit in preventing tartar buildup because they’re not as acidic as regular brands-which can be harmful to teeth enamel over time (source). This means it will actually do more for your dental health than traditional toothpaste. The best part about these products is that most are fluoride-free meaning there are fewer chances of developing cavities or having sensitivity problems with your teeth.
The Dangers of Artificial Fluoride
Fluoride is commonly found in both traditional and natural toothpaste products, but the difference between artificial fluoride vs. naturally-derived sodium fluoride will make a big impact on your oral health (source). Traditional brands are more likely to contain ingredients that may cause sensitivity like SLS/SLES or saccharin which can create plaque buildup over time – not to mention they’re harsh on our mouths as well! Natural versions have been shown to be much better for those who experience discomfort when brushing their teeth because of things such as SLS sensitivities or just sensitive skin in general. These less abrasive formulas only contain natural, organic ingredients that are kinder to mouths and teeth.
Why would you want to use natural toothpaste anyway?
- The best toothpaste for sensitive gums is one without SLS/SLES or saccharin which can cause sensitivity, but the list of chemicals in many brands make it hard to find those formulas (source).
- Some people use baking soda as a home remedy for this problem – just mix with water until you get the desired consistency and brush away!
- If your child has sensitive teeth from teething pain due to their new little pearly whites breaking through, using a mild fluoride formula might be the way to go. The Crest ProHealth Children’s toothpastes have been recommended by dentists since they’re specially formulated for kids who may be more sensitive to the effects of fluoride- a great idea since these toothpastes have been specially formulated for kids who may be more sensitive to the effects of fluoride.
- If sensitivity is not an issue but you are looking for natural products, check out Tom’s of Maine with their limited list of ingredients and no artificial colors or flavors!
- Toothpaste can also help prevent tartar buildup on teeth by providing protection from plaque acids in your mouth that cause decay, so look for formulas containing sodium monofluorophosphate which helps create a barrier against acid.
RiseWell Mineral Toothpaste
One family-friendly toothpaste that is popular with dentists around the globe is Xyla. Formulated with xylitol to tackle any cavity-causing bacteria and hydroxyapatite (an enamel strengthening ingredient used by NASA on astronauts returning from space), it’s also flavored with essential oils in case of accidental ingestion.
RiseWell Mineral Toothpaste uses all-natural ingredients like calcium carbonate powder (a safe alternative to fluoride), baking soda, tapioca starch and essential oils in place of synthetic preservatives or flavors. The brand has also been certified vegan by PETA as well as eco-friendly with no plastic packaging waste created from their manufacturing process! Their products have gone through rigorous quality checks at two independent third party laboratories where they were tested against 17 other leading brands.
Hello Sensitivity Toothpaste
I recommend any of the oral care products from Hello for their commitment to natural and organic ingredients. One fantastic product is their Fluoride Protection Toothpaste with potassium nitrate, which eases sensitivity in teeth and gums while also protecting against cavities. This product is also vegan, cruelty-free and gluten free.
Klēn Natural Mint Toothpaste
Fluoride-free toothpastes are gaining popularity and there are many to choose from. Many dentists are fans of Klēn’s toothpaste because “the ingredients are safe and it leaves the breath tasting fresh for hours on end.”
Klēn’s toothpaste are fluoride-free, vegan-friendly, gluten-free with natural ingredients that leave the breath tasting fresh for hours on end. Dentists love their products because they are safe and effective without any chemicals or artificial dyes.
Some of my favorite flavors include spearmint, coconut mint, and peppermint in addition to vanilla almond which is made from pure organic extracts like bananas, almonds, and vitamin E oil among other healthy substances. I also enjoy erythritol sweetener which has been shown to help balance bacterial flora in teeth promoting a healthier environment for your mouth while leaving it feeling clean at all times.
Tom’s of Maine Flouride-Free Antiplaque & Whitening Toothpaste
Tom’s of Maine has a wide selection to choose from, but as one of the original natural toothpaste brands on the market, we’re partial to this formula because it contains baking soda, which can help remove surface stains from teeth for a brighter smile. (Note: This pick does have SLS in it!)
Ojook Toothpaste with nHA + Bamboo Salt
I’ll start by saying that it’s difficult to compare this toothpaste to any others we’ve tried as the texture and taste are markedly different. The flavor is mild minty with a hint of pine (from the content). Aside from adding taste, pine can help soothe any pain resulting from gingivitis, gum disease or inflammation. Moreover, medicinal bamboo salt and nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) work to remineralize the enamel and prevent sensitivity. In sum: Aggressively minty this is not; rather, your mouth will feel fresh but unbothered after brushing teeth with this toothpaste.
Davids Premium Natural Toothpaste
This tube of toothpaste is different from most brands that use harsher, cheaper ingredients like sodium laurel sulfate or phosphoric acid. It contains baking soda and vegetable glycerin for a refreshing mint flavor and produces a generous amount of froth to leave your mouth feeling extra clean. The recyclable packaging comes with something extra too; it has a key so you can squeeze all the paste out!
Want to know the best part?
It’s inexpensive. The tube retails for $11-14, depending on size, but there are often sales and deals if you buy in bulk or subscribe for a monthly delivery subscription.
The price is low because Davids Premium Natural Toothpaste doesn’t contain titanium dioxide or carmine color (two of the most common additives used in commercial toothpastes). It also uses less packaging than mainstream brands, which may be appealing if you’re looking for more sustainable options when it comes to your purchases.
What’s not to love about this toothpaste? No gluten or sugar!
Himalaya Herbal Healthcare Neem And Pomegranate Toothpaste
It’s surprising that the foam of this toothpaste doesn’t contain any SLS or added foaming agents even though it still produces a satisfactory amount.
As a result, the toothpaste is also free from fluoride. This could be good for anyone who may have sensitivities to these chemicals or want to avoid them altogether. The ingredients in this paste include neem leaf extract and pomegranate fruit extract which are known as natural astringents that can help clean teeth by reducing plaque build-up on the surface of your teeth.
The foam produced was good without any added foaming agents. As a result, there’s no SLS found within this product along with being free from fluoride too! Neem Leaf Extract & Pomegranate Fruit Extact are both natural astringents so they’ll reduce plaque build-up on our teeth whilst cleaning!
According to many dentists, this best natural toothpaste is one that you can actually pronounce all of the ingredients!
The consistency was really smooth which made for an easy brushing experience with no grit left behind. The taste is supposed to be minty but it tastes more like sweet licorice in my opinion. It also leaves a strong aftertaste in your mouth if you brush too long – not something I would want as a regular thing so this isn’t my favorite ingredient about this paste’s flavor.
Vegetable glycerin has been shown to have anti-inflammatory properties and help reduce pain from inflammation caused by bacterial growth on teeth; however, there are some studies suggesting that vegetable glycerin could potentially cause mineral leaching or remineralization of the teeth. More research is needed on this topic for a definitive answer, but I am not so sure about putting glycerin in my toothpaste to be honest.
The sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) that you can find in some natural toothpastes has been linked with irritation and may lead to other health issues like eczema or dermatitis; if your skin reacts poorly to SLS then it might do worse when brushing with an oral care product containing it too. If you are allergic to nuts then avoid products with xylitol as well-it could cause anaphylactic shock because of cross-contamination.”
Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste
If you love Dr. B’s liquid castile soap, then you’ll be glad to know that their toothpaste product is perfect for lining your bathroom counter. Made with seventy percent organic ingredients and without any synthetic foaming agents, flavors or preservatives, it’s also Leaping Bunny certified (vegan). It is a little less abrasive than some other natural toothpaste so it might not be as effective for sensitive teeth.
If you want to avoid fluoride, then look for a product that lists sodium saccharin or stevia extract in the ingredients and contains no artificial flavors.”
Lebon Villa Noacarlina Toothpaste
By drawing from inspiration from nature and the sea, Lebon is as chic as toothpaste gets. Produced ethically with natural and organic ingredients in France, we love that the brand creates uniquely different flavors like sweet Moroccan mint and orange blossom (though we’re partial to this cinnamon variety).
-The olive oil in this toothpaste is great for polishing and it’s rich in antioxidants.
-It also contains shea butter which has a long list of benefits including moisturizing, repairing damage to the skin cells, helping with acne as well as allergies and asthma relief. In short: every person needs some shea butter in their life!
-This toothpaste comes from India originally but don’t let that deter you from picking up a tube; we love how natural ingredients are combined here such as neem leaf extract or peppermint oil. We do have one caution though–this product might not be ideal if you suffer from sensitive teeth because there’s more sodium bicarbonate than other natural toothpaste on the market.
-If you’re looking for a toothpaste with an aesthetic and taste that’s appealing to children, then this is your best bet–the flavor contains natural ingredients like honey or apple juice (we prefer not including artificial coloring) which might be more palatable than other flavors on the market.
-This company has been around since 1892 so if nothing else their longevity in the industry speaks volumes about how much we trust them. We also love how they focus on sustainability through minimal packaging and use of recycled materials but still produce quality products; it just goes to show what’s possible when businesses are conscious of environmental impact!
-This product stands out from all others because it uses Activated Charcoal as its main ingredient;
Bite Toothpaste Bits
Introducing Toothpaste BITS: these tiny toothpaste ‘capsules’ are made from all-natural ingredients like xylitol and calcium carbonate that are pressed into pill form. To use, wet your toothbrush and pop a capsule into your mouth. Then bite it down as you would normally brush your teeth. The travel-friendly capsules come in a plastic-free glass bottle and can be refilled monthly with the recommended one-time purchase, or purchased on demand for any trip to avoid baggage fees by ordering them online before you go!
-The benefits of using a zero-waste toothpaste capsule are many, including being able to avoid plastic from packaging and reducing your carbon footprint. Not only does this product come in the recyclable glass but it also leaves no residue on the brush when used which is impossible with traditional paste tubes. It also contains all-natural ingredients that leave you feeling fresh without getting any chemicals or fluoride into your system!
Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste
Tom’s of Maine Toothpaste with Fluoride and Baking Soda has no artificial sweeteners, preservatives, colors or flavors (and is not tested on animals). It also uses fluoride to remineralize and strengthen your enamel.
Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste is a customer favorite because it has fluoride, tastes great and removes all the stains from teeth. It also contains baking soda that helps to whiten your teeth by removing plaque on tooth surfaces. This product can be used in conjunction with any other type of Tom’s toothpaste without worry.
Jason Powersmile Anti-Cavity & Whitening Gel
This natural toothpaste doesn’t contain any SLS, parabens, or artificial sweeteners and it contains fluoride to protect against cavities. The toothpaste also includes bamboo powder and coenzyme Q10 for a more complete oral health boost.
This product contains more baking powder than your average toothpaste and has a whitening agent that will help remove stains from teeth.
It also includes essential oils like peppermint, eucalyptus, thyme, cedarwood, and turmeric to give you that light refreshing feeling during the morning or after dinner.
The addition of Aloe Vera helps soothe inflamed gums which may be caused by food allergies or periodontal disease.
Cleure Original Flavor-Free Toothpaste
Made with the singular goal of developing a toothpaste that was “free of chemicals that allergists, dermatologists, and cancer specialists consider unsafe or irritating,” this gentle option skips any fluoride, SLS, dyes, parabens, and even mint flavors.
Jack N’ Jill Natural Toothpaste
Let your kids choose from flavors like strawberry, blueberry or banana. Made with ingredients such as xylitol and calendula to prevent cavities and soothe gums, this easy-open top tube has been a family favorite since 1949. “For parents of young children, the flavor-free option is a great way to get them excited about brushing and then they won’t mind using it.” Dr. Rhea Kotva DDS
Revitin Natural Prebiotic Oral Care Toothpaste
Another option for those looking to switch up their toothpaste flavors is a citrus-based option by Dr. Gerry Curatola, a renowned biologic dentist. The best part? The toothpaste is free of SLS and fluoride and contains vitamins C and E, CoQ-10, prebiotics instead.
GREEN BEAVER Green Apple Toothpaste
Okay, so at the bottom of the list I have to say that this was the toothpaste that we disliked the most. This one is from the company Green Beaver, and the flavor is green apple. Now, the problem with this natural toothpaste is that it really just has a funny little aftertaste, and it basically tastes like baking soda. It just felt like we were putting baking soda with a bunch of green apple flavoring in there and it just didn’t taste right. My kids didn’t like it and I myself tried it and I really disliked it. This one is one on 10 for me. It was the worst one of the batch we tried. Sorry Green Beaver. Plus it smelled so good so it had so much potential, but it just tasted really, really bad.
Dr. Bronner’s Peppermint Toothpaste
- MADE WITH ORGANIC and FAIR TRADE INGREDIENTS: Dr. Bronner's All-One...
- NO SYNTHETIC FOAMING AGENTS: No Sodium Lauryl Sulfate, Sodium Lauroyl...
- A SIMPLE FORMULA: Hydrated Silica & Calcium Carbonate act as natural,...
- WHY FLUORIDE-FREE TOOTHPASTE: Research shows Americans are receiving...
- OUR TOOTHPASTE IS CRUELTY-FREE and NEVER TESTED ON ANIMALS: Dr....
Coming in at number five is Dr. Bronners’s Peppermint all in one toothpaste. Now, Dr. Bronners’s, I know online had a lot of great reviews. Some people absolutely swear by this toothpaste. Honestly, I just don’t know why it’s so well reviewed. It just tasted like a bunch of baking soda with peppermint in it. Really not a very pleasant texture. It didn’t really make my teeth feel clean, and I just find it has that kind of baking soda aftertaste that I just don’t like.
Unfortunately, this one didn’t do too well. It wasn’t awful, it’s not something that you’ll spit out right away, but it’s just not one that I’m going to ever buy again. And it was really expensive, I think I paid this one like 10 bucks or something. It wasn’t worth it for me. This one was just too expensive and not good.
Tom’s of Maine Simply White Natural Toothpaste
- WHAT YOU'LL GET: Six 4.7-ounce tubes of Tom's of Maine Simply White...
- WHITENING TOOTHPASTE: Uses naturally derived silicas to remove surface...
- CAVITY PROTECTION: Bring back the natural beauty of your smile and...
- ADA ACCEPTED: The only natural whitening toothpaste to earn the ADA...
- NATURAL & RESPONSIBLE: Contains no artificial preservatives, colors or...
At number four we have Tom’s of Maine, and they make a fluoride-free toothpaste. This one is Simply White toothpaste, and it’s peppermint flavored. Honestly, this one was the one that I would totally buy again. My son actually uses this one, he really likes it. The only thing I would have to say about Tom’s is that it does not foam up in the mouth like regular toothpaste, so it took us a little bit of time to get used to that. But honestly, the flavor was good, and it actually does make your mouth feel clean after you brush your teeth with it. This one was really in the middle.
It’s really not bad toothpaste, and I can totally buy this one again. It’s also very inexpensive and I think you can find it pretty much anywhere. They have it in the pharmacies, they also have it at Walmart, they have it online on Amazon. This one is still a good one. I mean, it’s not rated at the bottom, but it’s not my absolute favorite.
My Magic Mud – Activated Charcoal Toothpaste
- CLINICALLY PROVEN & 100% NATURAL - Our nature-infused flavors leave...
- MADE IN USA. CERTIFIED CRUELTY FREE & VEGAN - Fluoride-free,...
- MADE WITH INGREDIENTS FROM THE HEART - Made with earth-sourced...
- ENAMEL SAFE ACTIVATED CHARCOAL - Natural tooth whitener that removes...
- SATISFACTION GUARANTEED - Our 100% natural toothpaste is clinically...
Rated as number three, this one is actually my husband’s number one. This is where we differ. This is his absolute favorite toothpaste. This one is from My Magic Mud, whitening activated charcoal toothpaste. I bought this one at Amazon, and it really wasn’t that expensive, I think four dollars for this toothpaste. This one’s peppermint flavored, and I know they have a couple of other flavors. I think they have a cinnamon one, and I think they have a spearmint one if you find that peppermint is a little too strong.
The only bad thing I have to say about this one is that it does a mess in your sink when you’re spitting out the toothpaste. The black charcoal really does splatter everywhere, so you can’t wear nice clothing and then brush your teeth. You gotta brush your teeth while you’re still wearing your PJS or something and you don’t mind dirtying your T-shirt.
Personally, I don’t really like it because there’s tea tree oil in it and find that I can smell and taste the tea tree oil and I really, really don’t like anything that smells like pine. You can smell it a little bit, even though it’s peppermint flavor, I just find the tea tree oil was too strong for me, but my husband swears by this. I have to say, he’s been using it for a month and his teeth are so white, so the charcoal really does whiten the teeth super well. But this one is definitely my husband’s favorite and I recommend it highly if you’re looking for a whitening toothpaste.
Jack N’ Jill Natural Toothpaste
- MAKING TOOTHBRUSHING FUN FOR KIDS - Our Jack N’ Jill Toothpaste in...
- SPECIALLY FORMULATED FOR YOUNG TEETH - Natural ingredients, such as...
- WE HAVE OUR OWN KIDS TOO! - We know how hard it is to get young ones...
- ALL NATURAL & SAFE - At Jack N' Jill, we believe that businesses have...
- 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEED - If for any reason you are not satisfied...
Number two on the list is Jack N’ Jill’s Natural Toothpaste. Now this one is my younger son’s favorite toothpaste. This one is in the flavor raspberry. I know they have a lot of different flavors like, I think they have strawberry, banana. The banana’s super popular, I know that, and I couple of other ones. But, raspberry is my son’s favorite flavor. It smells amazing. Apparently, this one is completely edible, so even if your child swallows it, it’s super safe. It’s very expensive. A small tube-like this for me, cost me like, I don’t, $11 or something for a tiny little tube like this. I just found it a little expensive.
But if you have really young children and you’re worried about them swallowing the toothpaste, what’s great about the Jack N’ Jill toothpaste is that it’s made from a 100% natural ingredients, so there’s no artificial flavors, no artificial scents. It’s transparent toothpaste. Honestly, it’s really good, you can actually eat this stuff, it’s so good. But, for me, I just can’t use this kind of stuff on me, it just doesn’t make your mouth feel clean. But for really young children this is the best natural toothpaste out there.
JASON Sea Fresh Strengthening Fluoride-Free Toothpaste
- One 6 oz. tube of JASON Sea Fresh Strengthening Fluoride-Free Deep Sea...
- Helps brighten your smile and freshen your breath without the use of...
- Contains botanicals such as blue green algae, spearmint and parsley
- Free of fluoride, gluten, saccharin, artificial sweeteners, parabens,...
- Not tested on animals
Number one on the list for me personally was Jason Sea Fresh Strengthening Toothpaste. I don’t know why I can’t say strengthening, but it’s Jason Sea Fresh Strengthening Toothpaste. This one is the most conventional toothpaste. It does have a little bit of a foaming action. It has a really nice spearmint flavor, it really freshens my breath, and my teeth feel super clean after I brush my teeth with this one. Honesty, it tasted the best, it had the best texture, and it really did clean my teeth properly. So, this is number one for me.
In this post, I review a range of toothpastes that are safe for your entire family. Whether you need fluoride-free or natural formula, we have the perfect solution to help everyone in your home feel confident about their oral health. Our best Natural Toothpastes are free of artificial flavors and colors which can be harmful to sensitive teeth and gums. It also protects against cavities with its fluoride-free formula while leaving your breath smelling fresh, too!